3 Common Investment Mistakes That Destroy Wealth & How to Avoid Them

Learn how to identify and avoid the three critical investment mistakes in ideas, numbers, and behaviours that prevent 90% of investors from building lasting wealth.

Most investors sabotage themselves through investment mistakes long before market conditions get the chance. According to research, 80% of individual investors underperform market indexes primarily due to these self-inflicted errors. While many obsess over finding the next big winner, successful investing is often more about what you don't do than what you do.

DISCLAIMER
This article provides general information and analysis only; it is not financial advice. Neither AQ Media nor the authors are licensed financial advisors. Readers should always consult multiple sources and ideally with a qualified financial professional before making decisions about their financial matters.

Introduction

During my fifteen years in the financial industry, I've observed a fascinating pattern: the investors who consistently build wealth over time aren't necessarily the ones with extraordinary stock-picking abilities. Rather, they're the ones who systematically avoid catastrophic investment mistakes that plague most market participants.

As investment expert Barry Ritholtz puts it in his new book, "How Not to Invest: The Ideas, Numbers, and Behaviors That Destroy Wealth — And How to Avoid Them," the key to investment success is to "make fewer unforced errors." According to Ritholtz, if you just avoid three major categories of investment mistakes, you're "miles ahead of your peer investors."

The data supports this approach. A landmark Dalbar study revealed that while the S&P 500 returned an average of 10.2% annually over 30 years, the average equity fund investor earned just 5.3% due to these three categories of mistakes. The wealth difference between these returns is staggering—$1,000 invested at 10.2% for 30 years yields $18,900, while the same amount at 5.3% yields only $4,700.

Let's examine what's happening beneath the surface of these three wealth-destroying investment mistakes and how to systematically avoid them.

Investment Mistake #1: Falling for Bad Ideas

Bad investment ideas are everywhere and represent perhaps the most common investment mistake. In Ritholtz's words, "wherever you look, people want to tell you what to do with your money. It's a fire hose of stuff." The marketplace of investment advice is relentless, with everyone from social media "finfluencers" to your neighbor pushing their latest discovery.

The market narrative here misses three critical factors that lead to this investment mistake:

  1. Most 'opportunities' fail: For every successful investment like Hamilton or Nobu that becomes legendary, there are thousands of failed ventures that disappear without a trace. We have a distorted viewpoint because we only see the winners. Research from Cambridge Associates shows that approximately 60% of venture capital investments return less than the original capital invested.
  2. Complexity sells but rarely delivers: Complex investment products and strategies often exist primarily to generate fees, not returns. During my time at investment banks, I witnessed how products were engineered to appear sophisticated while primarily benefiting their creators. Studies from Standard & Poor's consistently show that about 85% of complex, actively managed investment strategies underperform their simpler benchmark indices over 10-year periods.
  3. Skepticism is your ally: Cultivating a healthy skepticism about investment advice is essential. Just because someone sounds authoritative doesn't mean they have your best interests at heart. The average financial product seller earns 5-10 times more from high-commission products than from products that typically perform better for investors.

When I lived in Hong Kong, I observed firsthand how rapidly investment fads would sweep through communities, creating temporary millionaires who often lost everything just as quickly when the bubble burst. During the peak of cryptocurrency enthusiasm in 2017, I watched neighbors liquidate real estate to purchase digital tokens that later lost 90% of their value. The cycle repeats because each generation thinks they've discovered something new, when they're often repeating old patterns.

How to Avoid This Investment Mistake:

  1. Implement a cooling-off period: Never act on investment ideas immediately. Give yourself at least 72 hours to research and consider any investment before committing funds.
  2. Ask who benefits: For any investment product, understand exactly how and how much the seller is compensated.
  3. Demand evidence: Request historical performance data spanning multiple market cycles, not just recent periods.
  4. Seek simplicity: If you can't explain an investment to a 12-year-old, it's probably too complex for your portfolio.

Investment Mistake #2: Misunderstanding the Numbers

The second category of wealth-destroying investment mistakes involves our failure to properly understand and apply mathematical concepts to our investments.

According to Ritholtz, the biggest numerical mistake is that "we fail to understand how powerful compounding is." This mathematical principle transforms modest, consistent investing into substantial wealth over time, yet most investors significantly underestimate its effects.

To illustrate: $10,000 invested at 10% annually becomes $25,937 after 10 years, $67,275 after 20 years, and a staggering $174,494 after 30 years. The growth accelerates dramatically in later years—something our brains aren't wired to intuitively grasp.

The tech sector's valuations provide a perfect example of this misunderstanding. My Silicon Valley contacts frequently share stories of talented engineers abandoning secure positions with healthy equity packages to chase quick wins at startups, not realizing that compounding their existing equity over time would likely outperform most high-risk ventures. In fact, data from a major tech compensation study showed that engineers who stayed at established companies for 7+ years often accumulated 2-3 times more wealth than peers who hopped between startups.

Other numerical errors that destroy wealth include:

  • Overestimating returns: Historical stock market returns average around 10% annually before inflation, yet many investors build plans assuming much higher performance. A Schroders survey found that retail investors globally expect returns of 15.3% per year—a number that has almost never been sustained over long periods.
  • Ignoring fees: Even a 1% annual fee can reduce your overall returns by 25% over 30 years due to compounding. On a $100,000 investment growing at 8% annually, a 1% fee difference results in approximately $200,000 less wealth after 30 years ($1,006,266 vs. $761,225).
  • Miscalculating risk tolerance: Most investors overestimate their ability to weather market downturns, leading to panic selling at the worst possible time. Studies from Dalbar show that during market corrections, the average investor's actual behavior results in returns 4-5 percentage points lower than the funds they invest in.
  • Focusing on nominal rather than real returns: Many investors fail to account for inflation. A 7% nominal return during 3% inflation is actually only a 4% real return.

How to Avoid This Investment Mistake:

  1. Use calculation tools: Regularly use compound interest calculators to understand the true impact of returns, fees, and time on your investments.
  2. Lower your return expectations: Build financial plans using conservative return assumptions (7-8% for equities) rather than optimistic ones.
  3. Prioritize fee reduction: Compare the total expense ratio of all investment options and favor low-cost alternatives.
  4. Create visual reminders: Chart the potential growth of your investments to make the abstract concept of compounding more concrete.

Investment Mistake #3: Self-Destructive Behaviors

The third and perhaps most damaging category involves the behavioral investment mistakes investors make. Even with sound investment ideas and proper mathematical understanding, human psychology often sabotages investment success.

These behavioral pitfalls include:

  • Chasing performance: The persistent tendency to buy high and sell low by following recent performance. Morningstar research shows that investor returns typically lag fund returns by 1.7% annually due to timing mistakes—buying after good performance and selling after poor performance.
  • Overconfidence: Believing you have special insight or ability to time the market. A landmark study by Barber and Odean found that the most active traders underperformed the market by 6.5% annually, largely due to overconfidence in their abilities.
  • Loss aversion: The psychological pain of losses outweighs the pleasure of gains, leading to poor decision-making. Nobel laureate Daniel Kahneman's research demonstrates that the negative emotion from losing $1,000 is approximately twice as powerful as the positive emotion from gaining $1,000.
  • Confirmation bias: Seeking information that confirms existing beliefs while ignoring contrary evidence. One study found that investors were 50% more likely to read analyses that supported their existing investment theses than those that challenged them.
  • Recency bias: Giving disproportionate weight to recent events when making decisions. After bull markets, investor risk tolerance surveys typically show a 20-30% increase in willingness to take risk—exactly when caution may be warranted.
  • Herd mentality: Following what others are doing rather than adhering to your own strategy. During the dot-com bubble, approximately 80% of day traders were losing money while the number of participants continued to increase.

During the 2008 financial crisis, I witnessed countless capable investors abandon sound strategies at precisely the wrong moment. One particular client withdrew $2 million from equities in March 2009—almost exactly at the market bottom—and never reentered, missing the subsequent 400% recovery. The market collapsed not just because of structural issues, but because human behavior amplified every problem.

How to Avoid This Investment Mistake:

  1. Automate critical investment decisions: Set up automatic contributions, rebalancing, and dividend reinvestment to remove emotional decision points.
  2. Create an investment policy statement: Document your investment strategy, risk tolerance, time horizon, and rules for buying and selling before market turbulence clouds judgment.
  3. Implement accountability mechanisms: Share your investment policy with a trusted advisor or partner who can help you stick to your plan during emotional market periods.
  4. Study your own past mistakes: Keep an investment journal documenting not just what you did, but why you did it, to identify your personal behavioral patterns.
  5. Deliberately seek contrary opinions: For any investment thesis, actively search for the strongest arguments against your position.

Why These Investment Mistakes Are So Common

It's worth asking why these investment mistakes persist when they're well-documented and extensively researched. The answer lies in the disconnect between what we think we know and what we actually know—a theme Ritholtz explores throughout his book.

Just as The Beatles and Spielberg's "Raiders of the Lost Ark" were initially panned by critics while Elizabeth Holmes was lauded before her downfall, our ability to assess investment quality in real-time is remarkably poor. Without the benefit of hindsight, we're all susceptible to these critical investment mistakes.

Several factors make these mistakes particularly persistent:

  1. Evolutionary psychology: Our brains evolved to handle short-term threats and opportunities, not long-term probabilistic thinking. Studies from evolutionary psychology show that our cognitive architecture is designed for immediate survival challenges, not financial markets.
  2. Information asymmetry: Professional financial institutions often have informational advantages over individual investors. JP Morgan estimates that institutional investors spend over $130 billion annually on financial data and analytics, creating an uneven playing field.
  3. Media incentives: Financial media thrives on excitement, not education. CNBC's viewership typically increases 30-40% during market volatility, incentivizing coverage that provokes emotional reactions rather than thoughtful analysis.
  4. Survivorship bias: We primarily see successful investments, not failures. For every Warren Buffett profiled in the media, thousands of failed investors disappear from view, creating a distorted picture of what's possible.

Financial media contributes to this problem by highlighting exceptional cases that distort our perception. Warren Buffett and Peter Lynch aren't investment templates—they're outliers. Ritholtz calls them "mutants" whose success can't be readily replicated. A study by Arizona State University found that only 0.15% of professional fund managers consistently outperformed their benchmarks over a 15-year period.

The typical investor would be better served focusing on avoiding disasters rather than chasing unicorns. After all, investment success is often about surviving long enough for compounding to work its magic. As Charlie Munger famously noted, "The first rule of compounding is to never interrupt it unnecessarily."

How to Implement a Better Investment Strategy

Now that we understand the three major categories of investment mistakes, let's look at practical steps to implement a strategy that systematically avoids them. The framework below is designed to minimize each type of investment mistake through specific, actionable steps:

1. Create a Simple, Evidence-Based Investment Plan

  • Build a diversified portfolio appropriate for your time horizon: Allocate assets based on when you need the money, not market predictions. Research from Vanguard shows that 88% of your long-term investment outcome is determined by asset allocation, not individual security selection.
  • Focus on low-cost index funds for core positions: Use broad-market index funds with expense ratios below 0.2% for at least 80% of your portfolio. Studies consistently show that low-cost index funds outperform approximately 80-90% of actively managed funds over 15-year periods.
  • Automate contributions to remove emotional decision-making: Set up automatic transfers on payday to ensure consistent investing regardless of market conditions. Participants in automatic enrollment 401(k) plans have approximately 50% higher participation rates than those in opt-in plans.
  • Document your investment policy: Create a written statement detailing your investment goals, time horizon, risk tolerance, asset allocation, and rules for buying and selling. Research from Morningstar shows that investors with written plans are 60% more likely to stay the course during market downturns.

2. Implement a Systematic Review Process

  • Schedule quarterly portfolio reviews: Set calendar reminders for quarterly reviews to assess if your portfolio needs rebalancing. More frequent reviews often lead to overtrading and worse outcomes.
  • Establish clear rebalancing thresholds: Decide in advance what portfolio drift (e.g., 5% from target allocations) will trigger rebalancing actions. This prevents emotional responses to market movements.
  • Create a decision journal: Document every significant investment decision, including the rationale and expected outcome. Review these entries annually to identify patterns in your decision-making process.
  • Measure against appropriate benchmarks: Compare your performance to relevant indices over 3-5 year periods, not shorter timeframes. This prevents overreaction to short-term fluctuations.

3. Build Protection Against Behavioral Biases

  • Install friction before major changes: Require a 7-day cooling-off period before making any investment decision involving more than 5% of your portfolio. Studies show that even short waiting periods significantly reduce impulsive financial decisions.
  • Use accountability mechanisms: Share your investment plan with a trusted advisor or financially savvy friend who can help you adhere to your strategy during market volatility.
  • Limit investment media consumption: Research suggests that investors who check their portfolios daily make 25% more trades and earn approximately 0.5% lower annual returns than those who check monthly.
  • Consider a fiduciary financial advisor: If your portfolio exceeds $250,000 or your situation is complex, a fee-only fiduciary advisor can provide valuable behavioral coaching. Vanguard research estimates that good behavioral coaching adds about 1.5% in annual returns for the average investor.

4. Continuously Educate Yourself

  • Focus on investment principles, not predictions: Study behavioral finance and fundamental investment concepts rather than market forecasts. The former remain true across market cycles; the latter are rarely accurate.
  • Read annual shareholder letters: Warren Buffett's letters to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders provide valuable investment wisdom without promoting specific actions.
  • Take a financial literacy course: Research shows that investors with higher financial literacy scores make 30% fewer investment mistakes than those with lower scores.

Conclusion

The path to investment success isn't through finding obscure opportunities or developing market-beating abilities. Rather, it's about systematically avoiding the three fundamental investment mistakes that destroy wealth: falling for bad ideas, misunderstanding investment mathematics, and succumbing to self-destructive behaviors.

By focusing on what not to do, you can indeed place yourself "miles ahead" of most investors, as Ritholtz suggests. Dalbar's research quantifies this advantage: the average investor who avoids these common mistakes can achieve returns 4-6 percentage points higher annually than those who don't. Over 30 years, this difference can result in more than three times the wealth accumulation.

The approach isn't glamorous or exciting, but it's effective—and in investing, effectiveness trumps excitement every time. As Warren Buffett famously noted, "The first rule of investment is don't lose money. The second rule is don't forget the first rule."

As I often remind my advisory clients, investing isn't about being brilliant; it's about not being stupid. Avoid these three critical investment mistakes, and you'll be well on your way to building lasting wealth while outperforming the vast majority of market participants.

FAQs

DISCLAIMER
This article provides general information and analysis only; it is not financial advice. Neither AQ Media nor the authors are licensed financial advisors. Readers should always consult multiple sources and ideally with a qualified financial professional before making decisions about their financial matters.

Isn't it more important to find great investment opportunities than to avoid mistakes?

While finding great investments is valuable, avoiding major investment mistakes is actually more important for most investors. Research from JP Morgan shows that eliminating large errors typically has a greater impact on long-term performance than finding exceptional winners. Their analysis found that avoiding the worst 10% of trading days would have improved returns by 80% over a 20-year period.

How can I tell if I'm getting bad investment advice?

Be skeptical of any advice that promises abnormally high returns, pressures you to act quickly, or doesn't clearly explain how the person giving advice is compensated. Legitimate investment advice acknowledges risks and uncertainties. The National Association of Personal Financial Advisors (NAPFA) recommends asking advisors these specific questions: 1) Are you a fiduciary 100% of the time? 2) How are you compensated? 3) What are your credentials? 4) Have you ever been disciplined by a regulatory body?

Are index funds really better than actively managed funds?

For most investors, yes. S&P Dow Jones Indices' SPIVA Scorecard consistently shows that approximately 80-90% of active funds underperform their benchmark indices over 15-year periods. While some active managers do outperform, identifying them in advance is extremely difficult. A landmark study by Laurent Barras, Olivier Scaillet, and Russ Wermers found that only about 0.6% of fund managers showed genuine skill after accounting for luck.

How much should I worry about market crashes?

Market downturns are inevitable parts of investing. Rather than trying to avoid them (which usually leads to investment mistake #3), build a portfolio that can withstand volatility and plan to invest through downturns. Since 1950, the S&P 500 has experienced 36 corrections of 10% or more (approximately one every two years) but has still delivered positive long-term returns. Creating an appropriate asset allocation based on your time horizon is more effective than trying to predict or avoid market corrections.

What's the biggest investment mistake you see new investors make?

New investors typically either take too much risk (chasing returns) or too little (staying in cash due to fear). Finding the appropriate risk level for your situation and sticking with it consistently is crucial. A survey by Fidelity found that millennial investors keep an average of 25% of their assets in cash—significantly higher than recommended for long-term goals and potentially costing them hundreds of thousands in foregone returns over their lifetimes.

How do I know if my investment fees are reasonable?

For passive index funds, look for expense ratios below 0.2% for U.S. equities and below 0.3% for international equities. For financial advice, a fee of 0.5-1% of assets under management is standard, though this should decline as your portfolio grows. Be especially wary of products with loads (sales charges) or surrender penalties, as these rarely benefit investors. The average investor pays approximately 1.5% in total fees across their portfolio, while optimised portfolios can reduce this to under 0.5%.

How can I improve my investment behaviour during market downturns?

Research shows that having a written investment plan increases the likelihood of sticking with your strategy by about 60% during market stress. Other effective techniques include: 1) Limiting how often you check your portfolio (monthly rather than daily), 2) Having a designated "investment buddy" who can provide accountability, and 3) Keeping a decision journal to recognise your own patterns of emotional decision-making.

Should I use dollar-cost averaging or invest a lump sum?

Research from Vanguard found that lump-sum investing outperforms dollar-cost averaging about two-thirds of the time over 10-year periods. However, dollar-cost averaging can be psychologically easier and reduces the impact of investment mistakes for many people. If you're concerned about making behavioural mistakes with a large sum, dollar-cost averaging over 6-12 months is a reasonable compromise.


References

  1. Ritholtz, B. (2025). How Not to Invest: The Ideas, Numbers, and Behaviors That Destroy Wealth — And How to Avoid Them. Published March 18, 2025.
  2. Iacurci, G. (2025, March 28). Investors will be 'miles ahead' if they avoid these 3 things: expert. CNBC.
  3. DALBAR, Inc. (2023). Quantitative Analysis of Investor BehaviorDALBAR
  4. Vanguard Research. (2022). Putting a value on your value: Quantifying advisor's alphaVanguard
  5. Morningstar. (2024). Mind the Gap: Global Investor Returns ReportMorningstar
  6. Barber, B. M., & Odean, T. (2000). Trading is hazardous to your wealth: The common stock investment performance of individual investors. The Journal of Finance, 55(2), 773-806. Journal of Finance
  7. Kahneman, D., & Tversky, A. (1979). Prospect theory: An analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica, 47(2), 263-291.
  8. Common Investment Mistakes to Avoid
  9. The Psychology of Investing Decisions
  10. How Compound Interest Builds Wealth
  11. S&P Dow Jones Indices. (2024). SPIVA® U.S. ScorecardS&P Global
  12. Schroders. (2023). Global Investor StudySchroders
  13. Understanding Investment Risk Tolerance
  14. Building a Diversified Investment Portfolio

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to AQ Media.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.